The UK government’s most recent analysis of university departments has just been announced. It’s called the RAE (Research Assessment Excercise), and as its title hints it focuses primarily on research over teaching. See here for the Theology, Divinity and Religious Studies criteria of evaluation. Each staff member is expected to have 4 outputs [paragraph 21], which are things like journal articles, books, etc. [paragraph 16]. The rating on the quality of the outputs counts 80% towards the total score, as well as research environment (15%) and research esteem (5%). The research environment captures a) research students and studentships earned, b) research income, c) research structure, d) staffing policy, and e) research strategy. Each aspect is ranked on a scale of 4 (world-leading) to unclassified (falls below standard of nationally recognised work).
Durham topped the list of universities for Theology and Religion over perennials like Oxbridge, Edinburgh, and Aberdeen in two ways: 1) it has the highest average score and 2) it has the highest percentage of 4-ranked research activities. I may be biased, but I’d say I’m not surprised that Durham is at (or near) the top. However, you’ll notice quite a few universities bunched near the top, so Durham’s lead doesn’t put them in a class of their own. Though, this is just one more reason to go with Durham.
This could help Durham’s reputation outside the UK. I can say that I didn’t really know anything about the university until I started looking for UK programs. But they’ve got quite a history of scholars that many don’t associate with the university. Another, more tangible benefit is the government funding that is associated with RAE results.
Monday, 22 December 2008 at 1:31 am
It will be interesting to see how this news affects the Times ‘Good University Guide’ rankings for 2010. The guide for 2009 appears to be based on the 2001 RAE report, yet Durham is still ranked very high for theology (#3 overall). Could Durham eclipse Oxbridge next year?
http://extras.timesonline.co.uk/tol_gug/gooduniversityguide.php?subject=THEOLOGY
Monday, 22 December 2008 at 5:55 pm
Theology and Religion isn’t the only top department at Durham: Archaeology is rated first in the UK as well. I posted about it on my blog. It surely makes me feel good about coming here over some other places. Let’s hope it leads to more funding in both departments.
Tuesday, 23 December 2008 at 12:22 am
Great news!
Friday, 16 January 2009 at 11:35 am
[...] meditation by Rowan WilliamsDurham ranks 1st in the UKAn impressive list of books that if you get the time, you should [...]