I’m doing a review of Guy Water’s Justification and the New Perspectives on Paul. Water’s characterizes the NPP as semi-pelagian (like 2nd Temple Judaism and Medieval Catholicism). At first this seemed like polemics but after a second read of his book and a few other sites, I can see that there may be more to his argument. It’s just hard for me to think that Tom Wright is semi-pelagian. I’ll write more about my thoughts later, but what do y’all think?